TeleRead is in favor of as many books as possible being online for free to the public, in the Carnegie vein. Still, we've also mentioned subscription-based models, a possibility that even showed up in the first published article on TeleRead.
Now O'Reilly, one of our favorite publishers, has launched a new subscription experiment with Safari Online Bookshelf. Billy Barron, who was interested in TeleRead as far back as 1993, sees some overlaps even though Safari is commercial. Recently he reviewed the O'Reilly plan, and his words appear below.
While O'Reilly is a computer book publisher, we can envision a similar approach working particularly well for publishers in other niches such as romance novels even though the $14.99-a-month price might have to be somewhat lower. Such an endeavor could open up some interesting possibilities, especially if many publishing houses and perhaps other content providers were involved.
A TeleRead substitute? Hardly. The TeleRead plan is more integrated, both internally and externally. It calls, for example, for fixed links and a Webbish ability of writers and publishers to link directly to sections of other people's works, at least when permission is given (either generically or in a particular case). Also, it would allow local libraries an outstanding amount of freedom to customize access to the national collection and contribute to its development. TeleRead, too, would tie in closely with schools, which, by the way, isn't the worst way to hook the young on books.
Still, even with a less innovative and ambitious vision, a giant industrywide subscription plan would be a start--whether or not it was limited to particular genres. If publishers were sensible, they would collaborate closely with librarians and the Internet Archive. As a matter of fact, Brewster Kahle, archive cofounder, told a library gathering that a number of publishers are interested in working with him on business-model development. What a great chance to try out the models in real life for libraries and direct consumers alike, as opposed to the courts--perhaps using older titles and low-advance books at the start, where the stakes aren't so high. Maybe the project also could build partly on the expertise of, say, NetLibrary, which, though a valuable service, is far less comprehensive and usable than TeleRead would be. NetLibrary is part of OPAC and already has connections to real-life local libraries. And who knows? If the big players surprised us and allowed the inclusion of such advanced features as external linking to sections of books, at least as an option, then so much the better.
Meanwhile, as promised, here's the Barron review of Safari.
* * *
Safari Online Bookshelf
By Billy Barron
billy@metronet.com
O'Reilly and Associates offers an online book service called Safari Bookshelf, an interesting idea. Rather than buying paper books in the stores, you can access them online.
Safari contains more than 1,000 computer titles, though it should be pointed out that I noticed that they sometimes have more than one edition of the same book. The selection is not just O'Reilly. Pearson, which owns most of the other major computer publishing brands, is also represented. Only 75 percent of O'Reilly's titles are on the site due to problems related to different books being published in different technologies.
The way the site works is that when you get an account, you get a bookshelf with a number of slots (usually ten). Most books take up one slot, but some take more. To view the contents of a book, you have to move the book into one of your slots. Once in a slot, the book has to stay there for a month before you can remove it.
There is also a search function that lets you search all the books on the site. You will only be able to view one paragraph from the book based on the search. Then to see more of the book, you have to add the book to your bookshelf.
The cost for 10 slots is $14.99/month. There is pricing for additional slots and group pricing for corporations.
The Review
The site is easy enough to use. It only took me about 5 minutes to figure out how it completely worked.
I did find a minor bug where a book on my bookshelf didn't show up on one page but did on another one. When I came back to the a couple of days later, the problem seemed to have gone anyway. Besides that, the site has worked well.
During the period I was reviewing, I had two unusual book needs arise. The first was I needed to learn AS/400. I searched the site and found no titles available. Then I needed to get up to speed on RACF on the Mainframe. Found nothing on RACF and nothing on the mainframe. I thought next I would try PeopleSoft and SAP because I will need to know more about them soon. Not much help there.
The site is stocked full of Unix, Java, Windows, C and other common topics. The conclusion I have to draw from this is that if you are looking books on the regular old common topics, you will find it on Safari. On the other hand, if you need the esoteric book, you will be out of luck most likely.
I was initially concerned about filling up my 10 slots and then needing a critical book later and not finding a spot for it. I have tended to underuse the site due to this. Now after a month, I have realized that I should be more aggressive about using slots and that 10 slots is probably enough for my needs.
My overall feelings about the site is that it can be a good value if you use it properly and are in need of books on the most common topics. It is a goldmine for the entry level programmer as they can get access to a huge number of books at a low cost.
(Reproduced by permission from the Web site of the Java Metroplex User's Group in Dallas/Ft. Worth.)
Additional thoughts: Wonder how the O'Reilly plan addresses fair use at home and among friends. Under TeleRead, books paid for by a National Digital Library Fund could be freely shared, at least in the States, and it would even be to the advantage of content-providers to see them spread far and wide among TeleRead users, with new revenue coming from each access or new reader.
How about books not covered by the Fund? Perhaps there could be provisions for free sharing within the same household and among different devices owned by the same user.
The possibility also exists of book-locker arrangements allowing a reasonable number of friends or business associates to share, with a different price for the privilege--or else friends could read the book for free for a limited time. These concepts that have been mentioned by others in different contexts.
As for readers overseas, they might be able to access TeleRead books through individual purchases, personal subscription plans or the purchases of their own national digital library systems, which could have similar provisions for sharing.
However TeleRead handles sharing and the related issues of Digital Rights Management and foreign pick-ups, it is important that the plan avoid the serious restrictions that the music industry and a certain large software company in Redmond, Washington, have imposed on users.
One thing for the publishers to keep in mind is that today's readers like to graze rather than commit themselves immediatately to a full purchase. That's one of the glories of a subscription model and some provisions for file sharing--since less commitment is necessary to individual titles from the start.
Another thing to keep in mind is that, with the distractions of the Net, many readers are spending less time with books.
Simply put, publishers should worry less about the nuances of copyright law and more about survival of my favorite medium. $20 e-books won't cut it. - DR